

Share Your Opinion
Anonymously Rate Your Experience & Make Work BetterShare Your Opinion
Anonymously Rate Your Experience & Make Work BetterPolicygenius employees are 28% more likely to recommend Policygenius as a great place to work
| 48% | Promoters |
|---|---|
| 32% | Passives |
| 20% | Detractors |
Working at Policygenius is rated average by 34 employees, across various culture dimensions. Policygenius employees are most satisfied about CEO Rating, Manager, and Professional Development categories, putting Policygenius’s culture in the Top 30% compared to similar sized companies on Comparably and in the Top 20% compared to other companies in Buffalo, NY. See below in detail how working at Policygenius was rated by employees.
Overall Company Culture at Policygenius is rated B
Last updated months ago
Policygenius ranks in the Top 30% of other companies on Comparably with 51-200 Employees for Overall Company Culture Score
Share Your Opinion
Anonymously Rate Your Experience & Make Work BetterOut of 15 Policygenius employee reviews, 92% were positive. The remaining 8% were constructive reviews with the goal of helping Policygenius improve their work culture.
| Positive Reviews | 92% |
|---|---|
| Constructive Feedback | 8% |
What is the best part about your compensation package?Health benefits are a 100% covered!!!
What do you like best about the leadership team?They're normal, rational people and also the smartest people I've ever worked with. Jen's sense of humor permeates the office.
What are some of the best things about your team?Talented, funny, passionate people who actually care about helping the customer and making positive change.
"Policygenius provides insurance brokerage products and services including life, renters, long-term disability and pet insurances to individuals."
Policygenius was founded in 2014 and its current CEO is Jennifer Fitzgerald. Since its inception 12 years ago, Policygenius has grown to 70 employees.
Policygenius is a NYC-based tech startup with a mission to help people get the financial protection they need and have them feel good about it. We are changing a massive industry by making insurance shopping faster, friendlier and more transparent for online consumers. Since our launch in 2014, we’ve achieved rapid growth in a notoriously difficult industry and established ourselves as a pioneer in a now hot sector of FinTech. We're at an exciting inflection point, having raised over $52 million of venture capital, and we're focused on building out our powerhouse team. Think of us as a one-stop-shop for all the financial protection you’ll ever need.
| Headquarter | 22 W 19th St, 8th Flr York, NY 10011 United States of America |
|---|---|
| Website | www.policygenius.com |
| Founding Date | 2014 |
| Tel | |
| Company Status | Private |
| Jobs | www.policygenius.com/careers |
| Social Sites |
Policygenius competitors include Travelers, AmTrust Financial, and Assurant. Policygenius ranks 2nd in Overall Culture Score on Comparably vs its competitors. See below how Policygenius compares to its competitors with CEO Rankings, Product & Services, NPS, Pricing, Customer Services, Overall Culture Score, eNPS, Gender and Diversity Scores.

Policygenius has 70 employees. 34 employees at Policygenius have reviewed Policygenius across various culture dimensions, providing their opinions on items ranging from executive ratings to the pace at work. The latest review was months ago.
Overall, the 34 Policygenius employees give their leadership a grade of B+, or Top 20% of similar size companies on Comparably. This includes specific ratings of their executive team, CEO, and manager.
Employees at Policygenius are generally satisfied with their total compensation at Policygenius, which includes a combination of pay, stock and equity, and benefits.
Overall, employees at Policygenius are extremely happy with their team. 34 Participants grade the quality of their coworkers a B. The majority believe the meetings at Policygenius are effective, and the majority look forward to interacting with their coworkers.
The majority of employees at Policygenius believe the environment at Policygenius is positive. Most Participants believe the pace of work at Policygenius is comfortably fast. About 36% of the employees at Policygenius work 8 hours or less.
Overall, the employees at Policygenius are happy, based on their aggregated ratings of future outlook, customer perception, and their excitement going to work.

The prevailing opinion from employees about joining Policygenius is that the company was very prepared on their first day. Policygenius employees concluded that their overall onboarding experience was positive. 100% said their direct manager was helpful with their acclimation during the first 90 days. First impressions are important, and how prepared a company is on your first day leaves a lasting impression.
At Policygenius 100% of employees think their department KPIs and OKRs are clear. Employees’ understanding of Policygenius' KPIs and OKRs is essential for its success. Out of 2 Policygenius employees who’ve answered, “Are your company’s goals clear and are you invested in them?” 2 have said yes.
Jennifer’s approval rate is in the Top 10% of all CEOs of similar-sized companies on Comparably, and in the Top 10% compared to the CEOs of all other companies in Buffalo, NY. Policygenius’s CEO is highly regarded especially by employees with 6 to 10 Years experience, Male employees, and Caucasian employees. Compared to Policygenius’s competitors, Jennifer Fitzgerald ranks right above Travelers CEO Alan Schnitzer. Under Fitzgerald’s leadership, Policygenius employee respondents are most happy about their Manager and the company’s Professional Development. Compensation and Happiness are two areas, according to respondents, where Policygenius could stand to see real improvement.
The Policygenius Executive Team is rated a “B” and led by CEO Jennifer Fitzgerald, VP Operations Roberta Meo, and VP of Finance Kevin Fusick
Jennifer Fitzgerald CEO / President
Jennifer Fitzgerald serves as the CEO / President of Policygenius.
Roberta Meo VP Operations
Roberta Meo serves as the VP Operations of PolicyGenius Inc.. Roberta started at PolicyGenius Inc. in January of 2018.... read more
Kevin Fusick VP of Finance
Kevin Fusick serves as the VP of Finance of PolicyGenius Inc.. Kevin started at PolicyGenius Inc. in September of 2018.... read more
David Kaplan VP of Engineering
David Kaplan serves as the VP of Engineering of PolicyGenius Inc.. David started at PolicyGenius Inc. in July of 2018.... read more
Cindy Gordon VP of People
Cindy Gordon serves as the VP of People of PolicyGenius Inc.. Cindy started at PolicyGenius Inc. in March of 2016. Cindy... read more
Francois Lame Co-founder & Chief Product Officer
Francois Lame serves as the Co-founder & Chief Product Officer of PolicyGenius Inc.. Francois started at PolicyGenius... read more
Justin Ternullo Chief Design Officer
Justin Ternullo serves as the Chief Design Officer of PolicyGenius Inc.. Justin started at PolicyGenius Inc. in June of... read more
How much do people at Policygenius get paid? See the latest salaries by department and job title. The average estimated annual salary, including base and bonus, at Policygenius is $80,295, or $38 per hour, while the estimated median salary is $118,484, or $56 per hour.
At Policygenius, the highest paid job is a Sales Manager at $118,484 annually and the lowest is a Receptionist at $40,707 annually. Average Policygenius salaries by department include: Operations at $82,383, Business Development at $104,850, HR at $88,700, and Customer Support at $61,443. Half of Policygenius salaries are above $118,484.
16 employees at Policygenius rank their Compensation in the Bottom 40% of similar sized companies in the US (based on 48 ratings) while 15 employees at Policygenius rank their Perks And Benefits in the Top 35% of similar sized companies in the US (based on 15 ratings).
Last updated months ago.
| Summary | Salary Range | Percentile |
|---|---|---|
1st Percentile $62k | $62k | 1st Percentile |
20th Percentile $90k | $90k | 20th Percentile |
40th Percentile $118k | $118k | 40th Percentile |
60th Percentile $183k | $183k | 60th Percentile |
80th Percentile $233k | $233k | 80th Percentile |
100th Percentile $330k | $330k | 100th Percentile |
* Estimated salaries Estimated salaries are based on data provided anonymously by employees and/or estimated by other statistical methods.
The Diversity score provides insights into how diverse employees feel and rate their work experience at Policygenius across various culture dimensions.
Policygenius PTO policy is a critical component of the benefits package offered to employees.

No Recent Jobs found for Policygenius on Comparably
Mark that you are interested and we will alert you when there are new positions available listed on Comparably
In 2019, Policygenius applied for 1 H1B visas.
Policygenius has a total of 70 employees
H1B Applications Outcome
This data was calculated using publicly sourced data from OFLC Performance Data

Candidates By Department
All Industries | 50% | |
|---|---|---|
Sales | 38% | |
Product | 13% |
Candidates By Location
New York City | 50% | |
|---|---|---|
Denver | 13% | |
Millsboro | 13% | |
Brooklyn | 13% | |
Buffalo | 13% |
What is Policygenius address?
Policygenius location is at 22 W 19th St, 8th Flr
Who is the CEO of Policygenius?
Policygenius CEO is Jennifer Fitzgerald, their score by employees is 81
What is Policygenius eNPS?
The eNPS for Policygenius is 28
What is the salary for Business Analyst in Policygenius?
Business Analyst average salary in the US is 82k
What are the salaries in the Admin in Policygenius?
The average salaries for Admin in Policygenius is 43k