Robert Isom vs Scott Kirby | Comparably
Profile Image
VS
American Airlines Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
667
TOTAL
RATINGS
5376
United Airlines Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
596
TOTAL
RATINGS
4849

Robert Isom vs Scott Kirby

Robert Isom American Airlines' CEO
Robert Isom
American Airlines
Bottom 35%
Bottom 35% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
C-
64/100
VS
Scott Kirby United Airlines' CEO
Scott Kirby
United Airlines
Top 50%
Top 50% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
C+
68/100

American Airlines vs United Airlines CEO Comparison Summary

Employees at American Airlines rank Robert Isom in the Bottom 35% of CEOs in Dallas. Comparatively, employees at United Airlines rank Scott Kirby in the Top 50% of CEOs in Chicago. Employees rate their CEO differently based on the frequency of interaction, ability to affect company culture, and drive measurable results.

Gender Score

Robert Isom American Airlines' CEO
Robert Isom
American Airlines
Bottom 30%
Bottom 30% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
C-
Gender

Women at American Airlines rated their CEO a C-

Scott Kirby United Airlines' CEO
Scott Kirby
United Airlines
Bottom 45%
Bottom 45% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
C
Gender

Women at United Airlines rated their CEO a C

Diversity Score

Robert Isom American Airlines' CEO
Robert Isom
American Airlines
Bottom 30%
Bottom 30% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
C-
Diversity

Diverse Employees at American Airlines rated their CEO a C-

Scott Kirby United Airlines' CEO
Scott Kirby
United Airlines
Top 35%
Top 35% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
B
Diversity

Diverse Employees at United Airlines rated their CEO a B

Question:
Do you approve of your CEOs management style?

Question:
How would you rate the effectiveness of your CEO to drive business results?

Robert Isom American Airlines' CEO
Robert Isom
American Airlines
Excellent
15%
Good
15%
Average
23%
Poor
39%
Very Bad
8%
Scott Kirby United Airlines' CEO
Scott Kirby
United Airlines
Excellent
25%
Good
8%
Average
33%
Poor
17%
Very Bad
17%

Who Ranks the CEO highest?

At American Airlines, employees in the Communications department rate Robert Isom the highest. According to employees, Robert Isom's ability to drive business results is Poor. At United Airlines, the IT department's employees rate their CEO highest. And, 57% of United Airlines' employees approve of their CEO's management style.

Robert Isom American Airlines' CEO
Robert Isom
American Airlines
90/100Department - Communications
69/100Ethnicity - African American/Black
80/100Tenure - 5 to 10 Years
82/100Education - High school
79/100Experience - Entry Level
Scott Kirby United Airlines' CEO
Scott Kirby
United Airlines
78/100Department - IT
78/100Ethnicity - Asian or Pacific Islander
74/100Tenure - 1 to 2 Years
77/100Education - Master's
78/100Experience - 3 to 6 Years