

Share Your Opinion
Anonymously Rate Your Experience & Make Work BetterShare Your Opinion
Anonymously Rate Your Experience & Make Work BetterBrotherhood Mutual employees are 20% more likely to recommend Brotherhood Mutual as a great place to work
| 60% | Promoters |
|---|---|
| 0% | Passives |
| 40% | Detractors |
Working at Brotherhood Mutual is rated below average by 5 employees, across various culture dimensions. Brotherhood Mutual employees rate CEO Rating highest among all categories, and think that Environment and Perks And Benefits have the most room for improvement, putting Brotherhood Mutual’s culture in the Bottom 20% compared to similar sized companies on Comparably. See below in detail how working at Brotherhood Mutual was rated by employees.
Overall Company Culture at Brotherhood Mutual is rated D
Last updated months ago
Brotherhood Mutual ranks in the Bottom 20% of other companies on Comparably with for Overall Company Culture Score
Share Your Opinion
Anonymously Rate Your Experience & Make Work BetterOut of 10 Brotherhood Mutual employee reviews, 62% were positive. The remaining 38% were constructive reviews with the goal of helping Brotherhood Mutual improve their work culture.
| Positive Reviews | 62% |
|---|---|
| Constructive Feedback | 38% |
What did you like most about the interview process?The people that I interviewed with were the decision-makers.
What makes you most happy at work?Helping others as well as training others to be their best.
What are some of the best things about your team?They are good people. They work hard and want to put forth a good product.
What's going wrong and how can it be improved?The company needs to add WFH options. Employees will keep leaving if the company doesn't provide more flexibility.
What does the leadership team need to get better at?Communication with employees needs to improve.
What does the leadership team need to get better at?Get with the times and have WFH option.
| Headquarter |
|---|
5 employees at Brotherhood Mutual have reviewed Brotherhood Mutual across various culture dimensions, providing their opinions on items ranging from executive ratings to the pace at work. The latest review was months ago.
Overall, the 5 Brotherhood Mutual employees give their leadership a grade of D, or Bottom 20% of similar size companies. This includes specific ratings of their executive team, CEO, and manager.
Employees at Brotherhood Mutual are not very pleased with their total compensation at Brotherhood Mutual, which includes a combination of pay, stock and equity, and benefits.
Overall, employees at Brotherhood Mutual are pleased with their team. 5 Participants grade the quality of their coworkers a C. The majority believe the meetings at Brotherhood Mutual are effective, and the majority look forward to interacting with their coworkers.
The majority of employees at Brotherhood Mutual believe the environment at Brotherhood Mutual is positive. Most Participants believe the pace of work at Brotherhood Mutual is bureaucratic. About 25% of the employees at Brotherhood Mutual work 8 hours or less.
Overall, the employees at Brotherhood Mutual are generally happy, based on their aggregated ratings of future outlook, customer perception, and their excitement going to work.

The prevailing opinion from Comparably users about their company is that it was very prepared on their first day. Employees concluded that their overall onboarding experience was positive. 73% said their direct manager was helpful with their acclimation during the first 90 days. First impressions are important, and how prepared a company is on your first day leaves a lasting impression.
At this moment no Brotherhood Mutual employees have provided insight into whether or not they clearly understand Brotherhood Mutual's KPIs and OKRs.
The Brotherhood Mutual Executive Team is rated a “D”
Matt Hirschy Senior Vice President and Treasurer
Matt Hirschy serves as the Senior Vice President and Treasurer of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company. Matt started at... read more
Kathy Turpin Vice President Human Resources
Kathy Turpin serves as the Vice President Human Resources of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company. Kathy started at... read more
Michael Allison Chief Counsel
Michael Allison serves as the Chief Counsel of Brotherhood Mutual.
Tim Turner Director - Board Of Directors
Tim Turner serves as the Director - Board Of Directors of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company. Tim started at... read more
Scott Figgins Senior Vice President Insurance Operations
Scott Figgins serves as the Senior Vice President Insurance Operations of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company. Scott... read more
Hugh White VP-Strategic Relationships
Hugh White serves as the VP-Strategic Relationships of Brotherhood Mutual.
Dave Lantz VP - Claims
Dave Lantz serves as the VP - Claims of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company. Dave started at Brotherhood Mutual... read more
Josh Spencer VP & Chief Actuary
Josh Spencer serves as the VP & Chief Actuary of Brotherhood Mutual.
How much do people at Brotherhood Mutual get paid? See the latest salaries by department and job title. The average estimated annual salary, including base and bonus, at Brotherhood Mutual is $87,374, or $42 per hour, while the estimated median salary is $105,850, or $50 per hour.
At Brotherhood Mutual, the highest paid job is a Sales Manager at $114,717 annually and the lowest is a Bookkeeper at $42,938 annually. Average Brotherhood Mutual salaries by department include: Marketing at $78,710, Design at $71,620, Sales at $106,562, and HR at $91,504. Half of Brotherhood Mutual salaries are above $105,850.
4 employees at Brotherhood Mutual rank their Compensation in the Bottom 35% of similar sized companies (based on 13 ratings) while 4 employees at Brotherhood Mutual rank their Perks And Benefits in the Bottom 20% of similar sized companies (based on 5 ratings).
Last updated months ago.
| Summary | Salary Range | Percentile |
|---|---|---|
1st Percentile $63k | $63k | 1st Percentile |
20th Percentile $83k | $83k | 20th Percentile |
40th Percentile $104k | $104k | 40th Percentile |
60th Percentile $187k | $187k | 60th Percentile |
80th Percentile $270k | $270k | 80th Percentile |
100th Percentile $354k | $354k | 100th Percentile |
* Estimated salaries Estimated salaries are based on data provided anonymously by employees and/or estimated by other statistical methods.
The Diversity score provides insights into how diverse employees feel and rate their work experience at Brotherhood Mutual across various culture dimensions.
Brotherhood Mutual's PTO and Vacation policy typically gives 15-20 days off a year. Brotherhood Mutual's benefits and PTO Package averages to represent a $1000 -$1500 cash value per month.

No Recent Jobs found for Brotherhood Mutual on Comparably
Mark that you are interested and we will alert you when there are new positions available listed on Comparably
In 2019, Brotherhood Mutual applied for 1 H1B visas. Of the work permits applied for, 100% were approved.
H1B Applications Outcome
This data was calculated using publicly sourced data from OFLC Performance Data

What is Brotherhood Mutual eNPS?
The eNPS for Brotherhood Mutual is 20
What is the salary for Designer in Brotherhood Mutual?
Designer average salary in the US is 82k
What are the salaries in the Finance in Brotherhood Mutual?
The average salaries for Finance in Brotherhood Mutual is 74k