Shelter Insurance Competitors | Comparably
Comparably
Shelter Insurance
Shelter Insurance(R) will be a dynamic group of companies focused on providing financially secure insurance protection and services to individuals and businesses, a quality working environment, emphasis on easy-to-use services, a commitment to continuous improvement, and a passion for pleasing our customers. read more
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
11
TOTAL
RATINGS
179

Shelter Insurance Competitors

Shelter Insurance competitors include Allstate, American Family Insurance, State Farm Insurance, GEICO and Safeco Insurance. Shelter Insurance ranks 1st in Overall Culture Score on Comparably vs its competitors. See below how Shelter Insurance compares to its competitors with CEO Rankings, Product & Services, NPS, Pricing, Customer Services, Overall Culture Score, eNPS, Gender and Diversity Scores.

CEO Rank
3rd
eNPS Rank
4th
Gender Rank
N/A
Diversity Rank
2nd
Product Quality
1st
NPS Rank
4th
Pricing Rank
3rd
Customer Service
1st

See Shelter Insurance Culture vs Competitors:

Shelter Insurance Competitors
RankCompanyScore
1Shelter Insurance68
2Allstate67
3American Family Insurance66
4State Farm Insurance63
5GEICO58
6Safeco Insurance51
CEO Ratings Comparison

Shelter Insurance's CEO Score Ranks 3rd

11 Employees at Shelter Insurance rate a 65 out of 100, which ranks them 3rd below American Family Insurance's CEO,Jack Salzwedel. Last rating was 21 days ago.

  1. 1st
    Thomas Wilson Allstate's CEO
    Thomas Wilson
    Allstate
    69
    out of 100

    559 Employees at Allstate rate Thomas Wilson a 69 out of 100, which ranks them 1st out of Shelter Insurance's competitors. Last rating was today.

  2. 2nd
    Jack Salzwedel American Family Insurance's CEO
    Jack Salzwedel
    American Family Insurance
    68
    out of 100

    115 Employees at American Family Insurance rate Jack Salzwedel a 68 out of 100, which ranks them 2nd out of Shelter Insurance's competitors. Last rating was months ago.

  3. 3rd
    Shelter Insurance's CEO
    Shelter Insurance
    65
    out of 100
  4. 4th
    Michael Tipsord State Farm Insurance's CEO
    Michael Tipsord
    State Farm Insurance
    56
    out of 100

    1306 Employees at State Farm Insurance rate Michael Tipsord a 56 out of 100, which ranks them 4th out of Shelter Insurance's competitors. Last rating was 3 days ago.

  5. 5th
    Todd Combs GEICO's CEO
    Todd Combs
    GEICO
    44
    out of 100

    460 Employees at GEICO rate Todd Combs a 44 out of 100, which ranks them 5th out of Shelter Insurance's competitors. Last rating was 2 months ago.

  6. 6th
    Matthew Nickerson Safeco Insurance's CEO
    Matthew Nickerson
    Safeco Insurance
    43
    out of 100

    20 Employees at Safeco Insurance rate Matthew Nickerson a 43 out of 100, which ranks them 6th out of Shelter Insurance's competitors. Last rating was months ago.

CEO Ratings Comparison
RankCEOCompany Score
1Thomas WilsonAllstate69
2Jack SalzwedelAmerican Family Insurance68
3Shelter Insurance65
4Michael TipsordState Farm Insurance56
5Todd CombsGEICO44
6Matthew NickersonSafeco Insurance43
Product Quality Score Comparison

Shelter Insurance Ranks 1st in Product Quality Score

9 Customers rate Shelter Insurance's Product Quality Score a 3.2/5, which ranks it 1st against its competitors.

  1. 1st
    Shelter Insurance
    3.2 / 5
  2. 2nd
    Allstate
    2.3 / 5
  3. 3rd
    State Farm Insurance
    2.3 / 5
  4. 4th
    American Family Insurance
    2.3 / 5
  5. 5th
    GEICO
    1.8 / 5
  6. 6th
    Safeco Insurance
    1.5 / 5
Product Quality Score Comparison
RankCompany Score
1Shelter Insurance65
2Allstate47
3State Farm Insurance46
4American Family Insurance46
5GEICO37
6Safeco Insurance21
NPS Comparison

Shelter Insurance Ranks 4th in Net Promoter Score

10 Customers rate Shelter Insurance's Net Promoter Score a -50, which ranks it 4th against its competitors, below American Family Insurance. Net Promoter score tracks customers' overall score to this question - “On a scale from 0-10, how likely are you to recommend Shelter Insurance to a friend?”.

  1. 1st
    Allstate
    -31
  2. 2nd
    State Farm Insurance
    -39
  3. 3rd
    American Family Insurance
    -48
  4. 4th
    Shelter Insurance
    -50
  5. 5th
    GEICO
    -64
  6. 6th
    Safeco Insurance
    -93
NPS Comparison
RankCompany Score
1Allstate-31
2State Farm Insurance-39
3American Family Insurance-48
4Shelter Insurance-50
5GEICO-64
6Safeco Insurance-93
Pricing Score Comparison

Shelter Insurance Ranks 3rd in Pricing Score

8 Customers rate Shelter Insurance's Pricing Score a 2.1/5, which ranks it 3rd against its competitors, below State Farm Insurance.

  1. 1st
    Allstate
    2.3 / 5
  2. 2nd
    State Farm Insurance
    2.2 / 5
  3. 3rd
    Shelter Insurance
    2.1 / 5
  4. 4th
    American Family Insurance
    2 / 5
  5. 5th
    GEICO
    1.7 / 5
  6. 6th
    Safeco Insurance
    1.5 / 5
Pricing Score Comparison
RankCompany Score
1Allstate46
2State Farm Insurance45
3Shelter Insurance43
4American Family Insurance41
5GEICO35
6Safeco Insurance20
Customer Service Comparison

Shelter Insurance Ranks 1st in Customer Service

7 Customers rate Shelter Insurance's Customer Service a 2.7/5, which ranks it 1st against its competitors.

  1. 1st
    Shelter Insurance
    2.7 / 5
  2. 2nd
    Allstate
    2.4 / 5
  3. 3rd
    American Family Insurance
    2.3 / 5
  4. 4th
    State Farm Insurance
    2.2 / 5
  5. 5th
    GEICO
    1.8 / 5
  6. 6th
    Safeco Insurance
    1.5 / 5
Customer Service Comparison
RankCompany Score
1Shelter Insurance55
2Allstate48
3American Family Insurance46
4State Farm Insurance45
5GEICO36
6Safeco Insurance17
Overall Culture Score Comparison

Shelter Insurance Ranks 1st in Overall Culture Score

11 Employees rate Shelter Insurance's Overall Culture a 68/100, which ranks it 1st against its competitors. Overall Culture scores are aggregated from all of the questions employees at a company answer on Comparably.

  1. 1st
    Shelter Insurance
    68 / 100
  2. 2nd
    Allstate
    67 / 100
  3. 3rd
    American Family Insurance
    66 / 100
  4. 4th
    State Farm Insurance
    63 / 100
  5. 5th
    GEICO
    58 / 100
  6. 6th
    Safeco Insurance
    51 / 100
Overall Culture Score Comparison
RankCompany Score
1Shelter Insurance68
2Allstate67
3American Family Insurance66
4State Farm Insurance63
5GEICO58
6Safeco Insurance51
eNPS Comparison

Shelter Insurance Ranks 4th in Employee Net Promoter Score

11 Employees rate Shelter Insurance's Employee Net Promoter Score a -19, which ranks it 4th against its competitors, below State Farm Insurance. Employee Net Promoter score tracks employees' overall score to this question - “On a scale from 0-10, how likely are you to recommend working at Shelter Insurance to a friend?”.

  1. 1st
    Allstate
    3
  2. 2nd
    American Family Insurance
    -6
  3. 3rd
    State Farm Insurance
    -17
  4. 4th
    Shelter Insurance
    -19
  5. 5th
    GEICO
    -45
  6. 6th
    Safeco Insurance
    -47
eNPS Comparison
RankCompany eNPS
1Allstate3
2American Family Insurance-6
3State Farm Insurance-17
4Shelter Insurance-19
5GEICO-45
6Safeco Insurance-47
Gender Score Comparison
Not Enough Ratings To Rank Shelter Insurance
Anonymously rate my experience at Shelter Insurance
Diversity Score Comparison

Shelter Insurance Ranks 2nd in Diversity Score

3 Employees rate Shelter Insurance's Diversity Score a 71/100, which ranks it 2nd against its competitors, below American Family Insurance. The Diversity Score tracks how positively diverse employees rate their experience at Shelter Insurance.

  1. 1st
    American Family Insurance
    72 / 100
  2. 2nd
    Shelter Insurance
    71 / 100
  3. 3rd
    GEICO
    68 / 100
  4. 4th
    Allstate
    68 / 100
  5. 5th
    State Farm Insurance
    63 / 100
Diversity Score Comparison
RankCompany Score
1American Family Insurance72
2Shelter Insurance71
3GEICO68
4Allstate68
5State Farm Insurance63

Shelter Insurance's Company Page is Unclaimed

Claim Page

By Claiming, Free Access to Comparably Employer Tools

  • Recruit Great Talent
  • See How Your Company Culture Stacks Up
  • Access Comprehensive Salary Data
Learn More
×
Rate your company