Jim Umpleby vs Samuel Allen | Comparably
Profile Image
VS
Profile Image
Caterpillar Inc. Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
764
TOTAL
RATINGS
7791
John Deere Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
523
TOTAL
RATINGS
5057

Jim Umpleby vs Samuel Allen

Jim Umpleby Caterpillar Inc. CEO
Jim Umpleby
Caterpillar Inc.
Bottom 45%
Bottom 45% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
C
66/100
VS
Samuel Allen John Deere's CEO
Samuel Allen
John Deere
Bottom 45%
Bottom 45% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
C
67/100

Caterpillar Inc. vs John Deere CEO Comparison Summary

Employees at Caterpillar Inc. rank Jim Umpleby in the Bottom 40% of CEOs in Chicago. Similarly, employees at John Deere rank Samuel Allen in the Bottom 40% of CEOs in Iowa City, IA. Employees rate their CEO differently based on the frequency of interaction, ability to affect company culture, and drive measurable results.

Gender Score

Jim Umpleby Caterpillar Inc. CEO
Jim Umpleby
Caterpillar Inc.
Bottom 25%
Bottom 25% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
D+
Gender

Women at Caterpillar Inc. rated their CEO a D+

Samuel Allen John Deere's CEO
Samuel Allen
John Deere
Top 50%
Top 50% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
C+
Gender

Women at John Deere rated their CEO a C+

Diversity Score

Jim Umpleby Caterpillar Inc. CEO
Jim Umpleby
Caterpillar Inc.
Bottom 25%
Bottom 25% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
D+
Diversity

Diverse Employees at Caterpillar Inc. rated their CEO a D+

Samuel Allen John Deere's CEO
Samuel Allen
John Deere
Top 40%
Top 40% of Similar Size Companies on Comparably
B-
Diversity

Diverse Employees at John Deere rated their CEO a B-

Question:
Do you approve of your CEOs management style?

Question:
How would you rate the effectiveness of your CEO to drive business results?

Jim Umpleby Caterpillar Inc. CEO
Jim Umpleby
Caterpillar Inc.
Excellent
23%
Good
31%
Average
8%
Poor
23%
Very Bad
15%
Samuel Allen John Deere's CEO
Samuel Allen
John Deere
Excellent
0%
Good
50%
Average
50%
Poor
0%
Very Bad
0%

Who Ranks the CEO highest?

At Caterpillar Inc., employees in the Sales department rate Jim Umpleby the highest. According to employees, Jim Umpleby's ability to drive business results is Good. At John Deere, the Marketing department's employees rate their CEO highest. And, 56% of John Deere's employees approve of their CEO's management style.

Jim Umpleby Caterpillar Inc. CEO
Jim Umpleby
Caterpillar Inc.
80/100Department - Sales
74/100Ethnicity - Asian or Pacific Islander
87/100Tenure - Less than 1 Year
70/100Education - High school
67/100Experience - 1 to 3 Years
Samuel Allen John Deere's CEO
Samuel Allen
John Deere
89/100Department - Marketing
80/100Ethnicity - African American/Black
87/100Tenure - Over 10 Years
80/100Education - Master's
81/100Experience - 1 to 3 Years