Q&A With Amica Mutual Employees
A culture of doing the right thing, built on respect for customers and employees and brought to life by our deep commitment to volunteerism and community. Support throughout your career, with tailored training, development and advancement opportunities. Benefits that are generous, including a generous retirement plan. Security and stability reflected in our long company history and our grow-from-within career model.
How employees describe working at Amica Mutual
In the past, I've considered the customer service to be outstanding.
The rates are so high everyone is cancelling
Listen to me, I have been insured by Amica for 45 years & this is the first time they have been unreasonable about a claim! They want too TOTAL my car for some minor damage! A claim of $4300 for a car that THEY say is only valued @ $5700. I will think about changing all of my $00k insurance !!!!!!!!
The willingness to pay claims without a lot of arguments
Better chances of being promoted to officer
What it's like to work at Amica Mutual
- Amica Mutual employees generally work 8.5 hrs a day
- Employees at Amica Mutual report the work pace is extremely fast
- 75% of Amica Mutual employees look forward to interacting with their team every day
- Amica Mutual employees most often take 15-20 paid vacation and sick days each year
- 43% of Amica Mutual employees report they are happy with their work life balance
- Amica Mutual employees never get valuable feedback on how to improve at work
- 69% of Amica Mutual employees call their work environment negative
Q&A With Amica Mutual Employees
IDX: 25 TOT: 100
Who did you meet with during your interview? And how long did it take to hear back from Amica Mutual?
I went to the Home Office and met with several Assistant Vice Presidents. I heard back about two weeks later.
First the Account Mgr and SCS Mgr, then Branch Mgr and other employees.
How can I improve my chances of being hired at Amica Mutual?
Be on time. Be well spoken and know your table manners in case they take you to lunch. Have a good handshake. Be up on current events, the P&C industry (and local sports, that topic always seems to come up). Have a good sense of humor.
Be as phony and obsequious as possible.
What skills do you need to be successful in the Business Development department at Amica Mutual?
Be able to talk and follow orders.
How do you feel about Amica Mutual's future?
It’s not looking great given the historic employee turnover. Amica sells trust and relationships. Without enough employees to establish that trust and keep the relationships the boat will be running aground soon.
How flexible is your work schedule at Amica Mutual?
8 to 5 M-F plus nights and/or weekends to stay caught up.
What's the work from home policy like at Amica Mutual?
Look up the word “micromanage” in the dictionary and you’ll find Amica. Despite everyone successfully working from home during Covid, Amica is requiring most people return to the office 4 days per week. If working from home is important to you then Amica will be a poor fit.
Does Amica Mutual drug test or do a background check?
Yes and yes
What makes you the most proud about working at Amica Mutual?
Honesty, morale is so low right now there’s not much to be proud of. Feels like working in a coal mine some days.
What kind of relocation or moving stipends does Amica Mutual offer?
Limited
What is the best perk or benefit that Amica Mutual offers?
Pension plan plus a 401k (but the pension plan was recently phased out for new employees).
How hard is it to get promoted at Amica Mutual?
Promotions at Amica depend quite a bit on who your supervisor is and how much they work with you on improving your skills. Promotions only happen when you take on additional responsibilities. Many customer service positions get ‘capped out’ with no chance of promotions unless you’re willing to move/relocate.
What is the dress code at Amica Mutual?
Conservative. You cannot wear jeans if you interact with customers. No tennis shoes are permitted.
How often do employees get raises at Amica Mutual?
Raises are given annually, and the raises are typically between 2-2.75%
How can I get hired at Amica Mutual as a recent grad?
Have good communication skills, problem solving skills and focused on doing whatever makes the customer happy. Customer service trumps everything else at Amica.
What kind of people does Amica Mutual like to hire?
Friendly, outgoing people who don’t question authority.
What is your favorite thing about working for Amica?
Company has an excellent reputation in the industry.
What questions do they ask during the interview process at Amica Mutual?
They really just wanted to get to know you, and to see how you handled yourself in a social setting.
How does Amica Mutual handle HR issues?
All HR issues are handled by the corporate office (and they look out for Amica).
How innovative is Amica Mutual?
Well Amica still has a green screen so I guess that answers your question.
Does Amica Mutual have a volunteer program?
Yes, each employee is given the ability to volunteer one day per year.
What perk or benefit should Amica Mutual have?
An employee discount on Amica insurance policies. Ability to wear jeans every day. Flex time. Ability to buy time off.
How often do promotions happen at Amica Mutual?
At best, 18-24 months. Nobody gets promoted for just having been at the job for a certain amount of time. Promotions happen if a) your supervisor likes you b) all of your metrics are above average c) your work quality improves & you take on additional duties and d) the planets line up just right.
What are the most important soft skills I need to be successful at Amica Mutual?
Working at Amica is all about delivering the best possible customer service. Easier said than done given every customer has just suffered a loss. You need to be patient, be a good listener, be an excellent problem solver and think on your feet. All while someone is screaming at you on the phone.
What is Amica Mutual's policy towards pets in the workplace?
They aren’t allowed.
What is the daily attire at Amica Mutual?
Business casual. Jeans permitted on Fridays.

