Allstate vs American Financial Group | Comparably
Comparably
Profile Image
VS
Allstate Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
711
TOTAL
RATINGS
7747
American Financial Group Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
9
TOTAL
RATINGS
164

Allstate vs American Financial Group

Compare Allstate versus American Financial Group for CEO Rating, Overall Culture Score, Brand Ranking, and other ratings. Results were generated by 711 employees and customers of Allstate and 9 employees and customers of American Financial Group.

Allstate

Allstate's brand is ranked #122 in the list of Global Top 1000 Brands, as rated by customers of Allstate. Their current market cap is $31.46B.

American Financial Group

American Financial Group's brand is ranked #- in the list of Global Top 1000 Brands, as rated by customers of American Financial Group. Their current market cap is $9.84B.

2.3/5
Product Quality
3.7/5
2.3/5
Pricing
3.9/5
2.3/5
Customer Service
4/5
-33
NPS Score
28%Promoters
11%Passive
61%Detractors
75
NPS Score
75%Promoters
25%Passive
0%Detractors

Net Promoter Score
Winner by 108

See how Allstate compares to its competitors

State Farm Insurance
Liberty Mutual Insurance
Travelers
Farmers Insurance
Progressive Insurance
Prudential

See how American Financial Group compares to its competitors

Markel Corporation
United Services
Getin Holding

Working at Allstate vs Working at American Financial Group

Thomas Wilson Allstate's CEO
69 / 100

CEO Rating

Carl H. Lindner III and S. Craig Lindner American Financial Group's CEO
Carl H. Lindner III and S. Craig Lindner
84 / 100

CEO Rating
Winner by 15%

Allstate

Allstate doesn't have enough ratings to calculate the Team Culture Ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

American Financial Group

Employees at American Financial Group rate their CEO, Carl H. Lindner III and S. Craig Lindner, 84/100. This score is 15% higher than the scores of Allstate's CEO, Thomas Wilson.

CEO Score 69
CEO Score
CEO Score 84
Overall Culture 67
Overall Culture
Overall Culture 86
3
eNPS
78
Gender Score 69
Gender Score
Gender Score N/A
Diversity Score 68
Diversity Score
Diversity Score N/A
Perk And Benefits 62
Perk And Benefits
Perk And Benefits 83
Professional Dev. 57
Professional Dev.
Professional Dev. N/A

Overall Culture at Allstate vs American Financial Group

67
/ 100
Allstate

Employees at Allstate rate their Overall Culture a 67/100, with Business Development and Marketing as the two departments that rate their experience the highest.

86
/ 100
American Financial Group

Employees at American Financial Group rate their Overall Culture a /100.

Overall Culture
Winner by 19%

  • Allstate67
  • American Financial Group

Employee Net Promoter Score at Allstate vs American Financial Group

3
eNPS
Allstate
235 Promoters 42%
101 Passives 19%
219 Detractors 39%
78
eNPS
American Financial Group
7 Promoters 78%
2 Passives 22%
0 Detractors 0%

Employee Net Promoter Score
Winner by %

  • Allstate3
  • American Financial Group

Gender Score at Allstate vs American Financial Group

69
/ 100
Allstate

Employees at Allstate rate their Gender Score a 69/100, with Marketing and Customer Support as the two departments that rate their experience the highest.

Gender Score
Winner

0
/ 100
American Financial Group

American Financial Group doesn't have enough ratings to calculate Gender Score ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

  • Allstate69

Diversity Score at Allstate vs American Financial Group

68
/ 100
Allstate

Employees at Allstate rate their Diversity Score a 68/100, with Finance and IT as the two departments that rate their experience the highest.

Diversity Score
Winner

0
/ 100
American Financial Group

American Financial Group doesn't have enough ratings to calculate Diversity Score ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

  • Allstate68

Perk and Benefits Score at Allstate vs American Financial Group

62
/ 100
Allstate

Employees at Allstate rate their Perk and Benefits Score a 62/100, with Design and Marketing as the two departments that rate their experience the highest.

83
/ 100
American Financial Group

Employees at American Financial Group rate their Perk and Benefits Score a /100.

Perk and Benefits Score
Winner by 21%

  • Allstate62
  • American Financial Group

Professional Development Score at Allstate vs American Financial Group

57
/ 100
Allstate

Employees at Allstate rate their Professional Development Score a 57/100, with Finance and IT as the two departments that rate their experience the highest.

Professional Development Score
Winner

0
/ 100
American Financial Group

American Financial Group doesn't have enough ratings to calculate Professional Development Score ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

  • Allstate57

Leadership Culture Ratings vs American Financial Group

Allstate
68 / 100
American Financial Group
88 / 100

Allstate rates % lower than American Financial Group on Leadership Culture Ratings vs American Financial Group Ratings based on looking at 1801 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "How would you rate your executive team?" and "Do you feel comfortable giving your boss negative feedback?".

  • Allstate68
  • American Financial Group

Compensation Culture Ratings vs American Financial Group

Allstate
61 / 100
American Financial Group
80 / 100

Allstate rates % lower than American Financial Group on Compensation Culture Ratings vs American Financial Group Ratings based on looking at 1220 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "Are you satisfied with your stock/equity compensation?" and "Does your company give annual bonuses?".

  • Allstate61
  • American Financial Group

Team Culture Ratings vs American Financial Group

Allstate
73 / 100
American Financial Group
80 / 100

Allstate rates % lower than American Financial Group on Team Culture Ratings vs American Financial Group Ratings based on looking at 1078 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "What do your coworkers need to improve and how could you work together better?" and "What are some of the best things about your team?".

  • Allstate73
  • American Financial Group

Environment Culture Ratings vs American Financial Group

Allstate
69 / 100
American Financial Group
81 / 100

Allstate rates % lower than American Financial Group on Environment Culture Ratings vs American Financial Group Ratings based on looking at 1085 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "What's the work pace at your company?" and "Is your work environment positive or negative?".

  • Allstate69
  • American Financial Group

Sentiment Culture Ratings vs American Financial Group

Allstate
68 / 100
American Financial Group
89 / 100

Allstate rates % lower than American Financial Group on Sentiment Culture Ratings vs American Financial Group Ratings based on looking at 1279 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "How do your customers perceive your company?" and "What's going wrong and how can it be improved?".

  • Allstate68
  • American Financial Group

See how Allstate compares to its competitors

See how American Financial Group compares to its competitors