American Family Insurance vs Erie Insurance Group | Comparably
Comparably
Profile Image
VS
Profile Image
American Family Insurance Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
158
TOTAL
RATINGS
1530
Erie Insurance Group Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
61
TOTAL
RATINGS
589

American Family Insurance vs Erie Insurance Group

Compare American Family Insurance versus Erie Insurance Group for CEO Rating, Overall Culture Score, Brand Ranking, and other ratings. Results were generated by 158 employees and customers of American Family Insurance and 61 employees and customers of Erie Insurance Group.

American Family Insurance

American Family Insurance's brand is ranked #- in the list of Global Top 1000 Brands, as rated by customers of American Family Insurance. Their current valuation is $9.33B.

Erie Insurance Group

Erie Insurance Group's brand is ranked #- in the list of Global Top 1000 Brands, as rated by customers of Erie Insurance Group. Their current market cap is $11.83B.

2.3/5
Product Quality
3/5
2.1/5
Pricing
2.7/5
2.3/5
Customer Service
2.8/5
-48
NPS Score
23%Promoters
6%Passive
71%Detractors
-9
NPS Score
41%Promoters
9%Passive
50%Detractors

Net Promoter Score
Winner by 39

See how American Family Insurance compares to its competitors

State Farm Insurance
Allstate
Mercury Insurance
Mutual of Omaha
The Hanover Insurance Group
InsuranceHotline.com

See how Erie Insurance Group compares to its competitors

State Farm Insurance

Working at American Family Insurance vs Working at Erie Insurance Group

Jack Salzwedel American Family Insurance's CEO
68 / 100

CEO Rating

Timothy Necastro Erie Insurance Group's CEO
Timothy Necastro
78 / 100

CEO Rating
Winner by 10%

American Family Insurance

American Family Insurance doesn't have enough ratings to calculate the Team Culture Ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

Erie Insurance Group

Employees at Erie Insurance Group rate their CEO, Timothy Necastro, 78/100. This score is 10% higher than the scores of American Family Insurance's CEO, Jack Salzwedel. Employees in the Customer Support department rate Timothy Necastro the highest.

CEO Score 68
CEO Score
CEO Score 78
Overall Culture 65
Overall Culture
Overall Culture 79
-10
eNPS
23
Gender Score 62
Gender Score
Gender Score 86
Diversity Score 72
Diversity Score
Diversity Score N/A
Perk And Benefits 68
Perk And Benefits
Perk And Benefits 88
Professional Dev. 57
Professional Dev.
Professional Dev. 51

Overall Culture at American Family Insurance vs Erie Insurance Group

65
/ 100
American Family Insurance

Employees at American Family Insurance rate their Overall Culture a 65/100, with Engineering and Operations as the two departments that rate their experience the highest.

79
/ 100
Erie Insurance Group

Employees at Erie Insurance Group rate their Overall Culture a /100, with Customer Support as the department that rate their experience the highest.

Overall Culture
Winner by 14%

  • American Family Insurance
  • Erie Insurance Group79

Employee Net Promoter Score at American Family Insurance vs Erie Insurance Group

-10
eNPS
American Family Insurance
41 Promoters 34%
26 Passives 22%
52 Detractors 44%
23
eNPS
Erie Insurance Group
29 Promoters 55%
7 Passives 13%
17 Detractors 32%

Employee Net Promoter Score
Winner by %

  • American Family Insurance-10
  • Erie Insurance Group

Gender Score at American Family Insurance vs Erie Insurance Group

62
/ 100
American Family Insurance

Employees at American Family Insurance rate their Gender Score a 62/100, with Operations and Sales as the two departments that rate their experience the highest.

86
/ 100
Erie Insurance Group

Employees at Erie Insurance Group rate their Gender Score a /100, with Customer Support as the department that rate their experience the highest.

Gender Score
Winner by 24%

  • American Family Insurance62
  • Erie Insurance Group

Diversity Score at American Family Insurance vs Erie Insurance Group

72
/ 100
American Family Insurance

Employees at American Family Insurance rate their Diversity Score a 72/100, with IT as the department that rate their experience the highest.

Diversity Score
Winner

0
/ 100
Erie Insurance Group

Erie Insurance Group doesn't have enough ratings to calculate Diversity Score ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

  • American Family Insurance72

Perk and Benefits Score at American Family Insurance vs Erie Insurance Group

68
/ 100
American Family Insurance

Employees at American Family Insurance rate their Perk and Benefits Score a 68/100, with IT and Operations as the two departments that rate their experience the highest.

88
/ 100
Erie Insurance Group

Employees at Erie Insurance Group rate their Perk and Benefits Score a /100, with Customer Support as the department that rate their experience the highest.

Perk and Benefits Score
Winner by 20%

  • American Family Insurance68
  • Erie Insurance Group

Professional Development Score at American Family Insurance vs Erie Insurance Group

57
/ 100
American Family Insurance

Employees at American Family Insurance rate their Professional Development Score a 57/100, with Sales as the department that rate their experience the highest.

Professional Development Score
Winner by 6%

51
/ 100
Erie Insurance Group

Employees at Erie Insurance Group rate their Professional Development Score a /100.

  • American Family Insurance56
  • Erie Insurance Group

Leadership Culture Ratings vs Erie Insurance Group

American Family Insurance
64 / 100
Erie Insurance Group
80 / 100

American Family Insurance rates % lower than Erie Insurance Group on Leadership Culture Ratings vs Erie Insurance Group Ratings based on looking at 471 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "Do you approve of your CEOs management style?" and "What does the leadership team need to get better at?".

  • American Family Insurance64
  • Erie Insurance Group

Compensation Culture Ratings vs Erie Insurance Group

American Family Insurance
65 / 100
Erie Insurance Group
81 / 100

American Family Insurance rates % lower than Erie Insurance Group on Compensation Culture Ratings vs Erie Insurance Group Ratings based on looking at 332 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "Does your company give annual bonuses?" and "Do you believe you're paid fairly?".

  • American Family Insurance65
  • Erie Insurance Group

Team Culture Ratings vs Erie Insurance Group

American Family Insurance
68 / 100
Erie Insurance Group
86 / 100

American Family Insurance rates % lower than Erie Insurance Group on Team Culture Ratings vs Erie Insurance Group Ratings based on looking at 279 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "How would you rate the quality of your coworkers?" and "What are some of the best things about your team?".

  • American Family Insurance68
  • Erie Insurance Group

Environment Culture Ratings vs Erie Insurance Group

American Family Insurance
67 / 100
Erie Insurance Group
74 / 100

American Family Insurance rates % lower than Erie Insurance Group on Environment Culture Ratings vs Erie Insurance Group Ratings based on looking at 273 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "On average, how many hours do you work a day?" and "Is your work environment positive or negative?".

  • American Family Insurance67
  • Erie Insurance Group

Sentiment Culture Ratings vs Erie Insurance Group

American Family Insurance
67 / 100
Erie Insurance Group
76 / 100

American Family Insurance rates % lower than Erie Insurance Group on Sentiment Culture Ratings vs Erie Insurance Group Ratings based on looking at 366 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "How do your customers perceive your company?" and "Are you typically excited about going to work each day?".

  • American Family Insurance
  • Erie Insurance Group76

See how American Family Insurance compares to its competitors

See how Erie Insurance Group compares to its competitors