Columbus McKinnon vs McMaster-Carr | Comparably
Comparably
Profile Image
VS
Columbus McKinnon Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
18
TOTAL
RATINGS
176
McMaster-Carr Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
178
TOTAL
RATINGS
1490

Columbus McKinnon vs McMaster-Carr

Compare Columbus McKinnon versus McMaster-Carr for CEO Rating, Overall Culture Score, Brand Ranking, and other ratings. Results were generated by 18 employees and customers of Columbus McKinnon and 178 employees and customers of McMaster-Carr.

Columbus McKinnon

Columbus McKinnon's brand is ranked #- in the list of Global Top 1000 Brands, as rated by customers of Columbus McKinnon.

McMaster-Carr

McMaster-Carr's brand is ranked #782 in the list of Global Top 1000 Brands, as rated by customers of McMaster-Carr.

2.7/5
Product Quality
4.3/5
3/5
Pricing
4/5
2.7/5
Customer Service
4.2/5
-40
NPS Score
20%Promoters
20%Passive
60%Detractors
53
NPS Score
71%Promoters
11%Passive
18%Detractors

Net Promoter Score
Winner by 93

See how Columbus McKinnon compares to its competitors

Konecranes
Fastenal
MagneTek
Titan Machinery
Kubota
STAHL CraneSystems

Working at Columbus McKinnon vs Working at McMaster-Carr

Mark Morelli Columbus McKinnon's CEO
53 / 100

CEO Rating

James DeLaney McMaster-Carr's CEO
James DeLaney
55 / 100

CEO Rating
Winner by 2%

Columbus McKinnon

Columbus McKinnon doesn't have enough ratings to calculate the Team Culture Ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

McMaster-Carr

Employees at McMaster-Carr rate their CEO, James DeLaney, 55/100. This score is 2% higher than the scores of Columbus McKinnon's CEO, Mark Morelli. Employees in the Operations department rate James DeLaney the highest.

CEO Score 53
CEO Score
CEO Score 55
Overall Culture 54
Overall Culture
Overall Culture 61
-51
eNPS
-34
Gender Score N/A
Gender Score
Gender Score 53
Diversity Score N/A
Diversity Score
Diversity Score 51
Perk And Benefits 43
Perk And Benefits
Perk And Benefits 88
Professional Dev. N/A
Professional Dev.
Professional Dev. 47

Overall Culture at Columbus McKinnon vs McMaster-Carr

54
/ 100
Columbus McKinnon

Employees at Columbus McKinnon rate their Overall Culture a 54/100.

61
/ 100
McMaster-Carr

Employees at McMaster-Carr rate their Overall Culture a /100, with Operations as the department that rate their experience the highest.

Overall Culture
Winner by 7%

  • Columbus McKinnon
  • McMaster-Carr61

Employee Net Promoter Score at Columbus McKinnon vs McMaster-Carr

-51
eNPS
Columbus McKinnon
2 Promoters 12%
4 Passives 25%
10 Detractors 63%
-34
eNPS
McMaster-Carr
35 Promoters 25%
22 Passives 16%
82 Detractors 59%

Employee Net Promoter Score
Winner by %

  • Columbus McKinnon
  • McMaster-Carr-34

Gender Score at Columbus McKinnon vs McMaster-Carr

?
Not enough ratings
Columbus McKinnon

Columbus McKinnon doesn't have enough ratings to calculate Gender Score ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

?
Not enough ratings
McMaster-Carr

Employees at McMaster-Carr rate their Gender Score a /100.

Gender Score
Winner

  • McMaster-Carr52

Diversity Score at Columbus McKinnon vs McMaster-Carr

?
Not enough ratings
Columbus McKinnon

Columbus McKinnon doesn't have enough ratings to calculate Diversity Score ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

?
Not enough ratings
McMaster-Carr

Employees at McMaster-Carr rate their Diversity Score a /100.

Diversity Score
Winner

  • McMaster-Carr51

Perk and Benefits Score at Columbus McKinnon vs McMaster-Carr

43
/ 100
Columbus McKinnon

Employees at Columbus McKinnon rate their Perk and Benefits Score a 43/100.

88
/ 100
McMaster-Carr

Employees at McMaster-Carr rate their Perk and Benefits Score a /100, with Operations as the department that rate their experience the highest.

Perk and Benefits Score
Winner by 45%

  • Columbus McKinnon
  • McMaster-Carr88

Professional Development Score at Columbus McKinnon vs McMaster-Carr

?
Not enough ratings
Columbus McKinnon

Columbus McKinnon doesn't have enough ratings to calculate Professional Development Score ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

?
Not enough ratings
McMaster-Carr

Employees at McMaster-Carr rate their Professional Development Score a /100.

Professional Development Score
Winner

  • McMaster-Carr43

Leadership Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr

Columbus McKinnon
59 / 100

Leadership Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr
Winner by 6%

McMaster-Carr
53 / 100

Columbus McKinnon rates % higher than McMaster-Carr on Leadership Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr Ratings based on looking at 374 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "What does the leadership team need to get better at?" and "How often do you get valuable feedback on how to improve at work?".

  • Columbus McKinnon
  • McMaster-Carr53

Compensation Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr

Columbus McKinnon
50 / 100
McMaster-Carr
85 / 100

Columbus McKinnon rates % lower than McMaster-Carr on Compensation Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr Ratings based on looking at 270 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "Are you satisfied with your stock/equity compensation?" and "Are you satisfied with your Benefits?".

  • Columbus McKinnon
  • McMaster-Carr85

Team Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr

Columbus McKinnon
63 / 100

Team Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr
Winner by 5%

McMaster-Carr
58 / 100

Columbus McKinnon rates % higher than McMaster-Carr on Team Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr Ratings based on looking at 215 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "Do you look forward to interacting with your coworkers?" and "Does Your Boss Hurt Your Company Culture?".

  • Columbus McKinnon
  • McMaster-Carr57

Environment Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr

Columbus McKinnon
56 / 100
McMaster-Carr
62 / 100

Columbus McKinnon rates % lower than McMaster-Carr on Environment Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr Ratings based on looking at 196 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "What % of the time are you bored at work?" and "Do you have a close friend at work?".

  • Columbus McKinnon
  • McMaster-Carr62

Sentiment Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr

Columbus McKinnon
42 / 100
McMaster-Carr
59 / 100

Columbus McKinnon rates % lower than McMaster-Carr on Sentiment Culture Ratings vs McMaster-Carr Ratings based on looking at 309 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "What makes you most happy at work?" and "Are you typically excited about going to work each day?".

  • Columbus McKinnon
  • McMaster-Carr58

See how Columbus McKinnon compares to its competitors