Otter Tail Corporation vs Xcel Energy | Comparably
Comparably
VS
Otter Tail Corporation
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
6
TOTAL
RATINGS
110
Xcel Energy Claimed Company
EMPLOYEE
PARTICIPANTS
136
TOTAL
RATINGS
1207

Otter Tail Corporation vs Xcel Energy

Compare Otter Tail Corporation versus Xcel Energy for CEO Rating, Overall Culture Score, Brand Ranking, and other ratings. Results were generated by 6 employees and customers of Otter Tail Corporation and 136 employees and customers of Xcel Energy.

Otter Tail Corporation

Otter Tail Corporation's brand is ranked #- in the list of Global Top 1000 Brands, as rated by customers of Otter Tail Corporation. Their current market cap is $1.72B.

Xcel Energy

Xcel Energy's brand is ranked #702 in the list of Global Top 1000 Brands, as rated by customers of Xcel Energy. Their current market cap is $35.91B.

3.7/5
Product Quality
2.6/5
3.5/5
Pricing
2.2/5
3.7/5
Customer Service
2.4/5
50
NPS Score
50%Promoters
50%Passive
0%Detractors

Net Promoter Score
Winner by 92

-42
NPS Score
23%Promoters
12%Passive
65%Detractors

See how Otter Tail Corporation compares to its competitors

American Electric Power
Allete
NorthWestern Energy
Black Hills

See how Xcel Energy compares to its competitors

Entergy
American Electric Power
Allete
Edison International
Evaporcool
NextEra Energy
Southern Company

Working at Otter Tail Corporation vs Working at Xcel Energy

Chuck MacFarlane Otter Tail Corporation's CEO
55 / 100

CEO Rating

Benjamin G.S. Fowke III Xcel Energy's CEO
Benjamin G.S. Fowke III
61 / 100

CEO Rating
Winner by 6%

Otter Tail Corporation

Otter Tail Corporation doesn't have enough ratings to calculate the Team Culture Ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

Xcel Energy

Employees at Xcel Energy rate their CEO, Benjamin G.S. Fowke III, 61/100. This score is 6% higher than the scores of Otter Tail Corporation's CEO, Chuck MacFarlane. Employees in the Customer Support and Finance departments rate Benjamin G.S. Fowke III the highest.

CEO Score 55
CEO Score
CEO Score 61
Overall Culture 70
Overall Culture
Overall Culture 60
25
eNPS
-9
Gender Score N/A
Gender Score
Gender Score 69
Diversity Score N/A
Diversity Score
Diversity Score 61
Perk And Benefits 56
Perk And Benefits
Perk And Benefits 62
Professional Dev. N/A
Professional Dev.
Professional Dev. 37

Overall Culture at Otter Tail Corporation vs Xcel Energy

70
/ 100
Otter Tail Corporation

Employees at Otter Tail Corporation rate their Overall Culture a 70/100.

Overall Culture
Winner by 10%

60
/ 100
Xcel Energy

Employees at Xcel Energy rate their Overall Culture a /100, with Customer Support and HR as the two departments that rate their experience the highest.

  • Otter Tail Corporation
  • Xcel Energy60

Employee Net Promoter Score at Otter Tail Corporation vs Xcel Energy

25
eNPS
Otter Tail Corporation
2 Promoters 50%
1 Passives 25%
1 Detractors 25%

Employee Net Promoter Score
Winner by 34%

-9
eNPS
Xcel Energy
41 Promoters 39%
14 Passives 13%
51 Detractors 48%
  • Otter Tail Corporation
  • Xcel Energy-10

Gender Score at Otter Tail Corporation vs Xcel Energy

?
Not enough ratings
Otter Tail Corporation

Otter Tail Corporation doesn't have enough ratings to calculate Gender Score ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

?
Not enough ratings
Xcel Energy

Employees at Xcel Energy rate their Gender Score a /100, with Customer Support as the department that rate their experience the highest.

Gender Score
Winner

  • Xcel Energy69

Diversity Score at Otter Tail Corporation vs Xcel Energy

?
Not enough ratings
Otter Tail Corporation

Otter Tail Corporation doesn't have enough ratings to calculate Diversity Score ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

?
Not enough ratings
Xcel Energy

Employees at Xcel Energy rate their Diversity Score a /100.

Diversity Score
Winner

  • Xcel Energy61

Perk and Benefits Score at Otter Tail Corporation vs Xcel Energy

56
/ 100
Otter Tail Corporation

Employees at Otter Tail Corporation rate their Perk and Benefits Score a 56/100.

62
/ 100
Xcel Energy

Employees at Xcel Energy rate their Perk and Benefits Score a /100, with Customer Support and Finance as the two departments that rate their experience the highest.

Perk and Benefits Score
Winner by 6%

  • Otter Tail Corporation
  • Xcel Energy62

Professional Development Score at Otter Tail Corporation vs Xcel Energy

?
Not enough ratings
Otter Tail Corporation

Otter Tail Corporation doesn't have enough ratings to calculate Professional Development Score ratings.

Know someone that works there? Invite them to rate their experience.

?
Not enough ratings
Xcel Energy

Employees at Xcel Energy rate their Professional Development Score a /100, with IT as the department that rate their experience the highest.

Professional Development Score
Winner

  • Xcel Energy33

Leadership Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy

Otter Tail Corporation
72 / 100

Leadership Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy
Winner by 12%

Xcel Energy
60 / 100

Otter Tail Corporation rates % higher than Xcel Energy on Leadership Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy Ratings based on looking at 294 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "Do you approve of the job your executive team is doing at your company?" and "Is your company invested in your career growth?".

  • Otter Tail Corporation
  • Xcel Energy60

Compensation Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy

Otter Tail Corporation
70 / 100

Compensation Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy
Winner by 11%

Xcel Energy
59 / 100

Otter Tail Corporation rates % higher than Xcel Energy on Compensation Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy Ratings based on looking at 170 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "What is the best part about your compensation package?" and "Does your company give annual bonuses?".

  • Otter Tail Corporation
  • Xcel Energy59

Team Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy

Otter Tail Corporation
79 / 100

Team Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy
Winner by 15%

Xcel Energy
64 / 100

Otter Tail Corporation rates % higher than Xcel Energy on Team Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy Ratings based on looking at 155 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "What are some of the best things about your team?" and "Are your company's meetings effective?".

  • Otter Tail Corporation
  • Xcel Energy64

Environment Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy

Otter Tail Corporation
67 / 100

Environment Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy
Winner by 3%

Xcel Energy
64 / 100

Otter Tail Corporation rates % higher than Xcel Energy on Environment Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy Ratings based on looking at 168 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "What needs to change to make the company culture better?" and "Is your work environment positive or negative?".

  • Otter Tail Corporation
  • Xcel Energy64

Sentiment Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy

Otter Tail Corporation
75 / 100

Sentiment Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy
Winner by 14%

Xcel Energy
61 / 100

Otter Tail Corporation rates % higher than Xcel Energy on Sentiment Culture Ratings vs Xcel Energy Ratings based on looking at 237 ratings from employees of the two companies. Ratings come from the answers to questions like "What's going wrong and how can it be improved?" and "What would you most like to see improved at your company?".

  • Otter Tail Corporation
  • Xcel Energy61

See how Otter Tail Corporation compares to its competitors

See how Xcel Energy compares to its competitors