


Share Your Opinion
Anonymously Rate Your Experience & Make Work BetterShare Your Opinion
Anonymously Rate Your Experience & Make Work BetterGregory & Appel Insurance employees are -60% more likely to recommend Gregory & Appel Insurance as a great place to work
| 20% | Promoters |
|---|---|
| 0% | Passives |
| 80% | Detractors |
Working at Gregory & Appel Insurance is rated below average by 6 employees, across various culture dimensions. Gregory & Appel Insurance employees rate Manager highest among all categories, and think that Compensation and Team have the most room for improvement, putting Gregory & Appel Insurance’s culture in the Bottom 20% compared to similar sized companies on Comparably and in the Bottom 25% compared to other companies in Indianapolis, IN. See below in detail how working at Gregory & Appel Insurance was rated by employees.
Overall Company Culture at Gregory & Appel Insurance is rated D
Last updated months ago
Gregory & Appel Insurance ranks in the Bottom 20% of other companies on Comparably with 51-200 Employees for Overall Company Culture Score
Share Your Opinion
Anonymously Rate Your Experience & Make Work BetterOut of 8 Gregory & Appel Insurance employee reviews, 71% were positive. The remaining 29% were constructive reviews with the goal of helping Gregory & Appel Insurance improve their work culture.
| Positive Reviews | 71% |
|---|---|
| Constructive Feedback | 29% |
What are some of the best things about your team?The staff (not management) is willing to help out however, most employees are overloaded
What are some of the best things about your team?collaborative and supportive
What is most positive about the culture and environment at your company?best company culture
What's going wrong and how can it be improved?Management is not supporting staff or being transparent with them. They are overloading employees and burning them out quickly
What does the leadership team need to get better at?Keeping promises, following through, coming up with logical plans
Founded in 1884, Gregory & Appel is the oldest independently-owned insurance agency in Indiana. We’re also one of the largest. Our firm is privately held.
Founded in 1884, Gregory & Appel is the oldest independently-owned insurance agency in Indiana. We’re also one of the largest. Our firm is privately held and is in its fifth generation of family ownership. We balance a rich history of integrity, hard work and professionalism with innovation, technology, and creativity. Gregory & Appel Insurance offers a wide spectrum of property & casualty risk management and employee benefits solutions to businesses and individual clients throughout the Midwest and the world. Today, our employees specialize in protecting the physical assets and human capital of organizations with revenues under $1 billion.
| Headquarter | 1402 N Capitol Ave Ste 400 Indianapolis, IN 46202-2375 |
|---|---|
| Website | www.gregoryappel.com |
| Tel | 1-317-634-7491 |
| Company Status | Private |
| Jobs | www.gregoryappel.com/careers |
Gregory & Appel Insurance has 128 employees. 6 employees at Gregory & Appel Insurance have reviewed Gregory & Appel Insurance across various culture dimensions, providing their opinions on items ranging from executive ratings to the pace at work. The latest review was months ago.
Overall, the 6 Gregory & Appel Insurance employees give their leadership a grade of C-, or Bottom 30% of similar size companies. This includes specific ratings of their executive team, CEO, and manager.
Employees at Gregory & Appel Insurance are mostly dissatisfied with their total compensation at Gregory & Appel Insurance, which includes a combination of pay, stock and equity, and benefits.
Overall, employees at Gregory & Appel Insurance are not very pleased with their team. 6 Participants grade the quality of their coworkers a D. Less than half believe the meetings at Gregory & Appel Insurance are effective, and the majority look forward to interacting with their coworkers.
The majority of employees at Gregory & Appel Insurance believe the environment at Gregory & Appel Insurance is positive. Most Participants believe the pace of work at Gregory & Appel Insurance is moderate. About 50% of the employees at Gregory & Appel Insurance work 8 hours or less, while 25% of them have an extremely long day - longer than twelve hours.
Overall, the employees at Gregory & Appel Insurance are not very happy, based on their aggregated ratings of future outlook, customer perception, and their excitement going to work.

The prevailing opinion from Comparably users in Indianapolis, IN about their company is that it was prepared on their first day. Indianapolis, IN employees concluded that their overall onboarding experience was positive. 74% said their direct manager was helpful with their acclimation during the first 90 days. First impressions are important, and how prepared a company is on your first day leaves a lasting impression.
At this moment no Gregory & Appel Insurance employees have provided insight into whether or not they clearly understand Gregory & Appel Insurance's KPIs and OKRs.
Dan’s approval rate is lower compared to CEOs at similar sized companies, putting Dan in the Bottom 30% of all CEOs of similar-sized companies on Comparably, and in the Bottom 40% compared to CEOs of all other companies in Indianapolis, IN. Dan Appel’s employees rank Gregory & Appel Insurance in the Top 50% for Manager, in the Bottom 30% for Leadership, and in the Bottom 25% for Perks And Benefits.
The Gregory & Appel Insurance Executive Team is rated a “D” and led by CEO Dan Appel, Senior Vice President Brad Dumbauld, and Vice President Chad Morris
Dan Appel CEO / President
Dan Appel serves as the CEO / President of Gregory & Appel Insurance.
Brad Dumbauld Senior Vice President
Brad Dumbauld serves as the Senior Vice President of Gregory & Appel Insurance.
Chad Morris Vice President
Chad Morris serves as the Vice President of Gregory & Appel Insurance.
Christina Kelley Chief Operating Officer
Christina Kelley serves as the Chief Operating Officer of Gregory & Appel Insurance.
Jack Mahoney Senior Vice President and Managing Director
Jack Mahoney serves as the Senior Vice President and Managing Director of Gregory & Appel Insurance.
Jeff Webster Senior Vice President
Jeff Webster serves as the Senior Vice President of Gregory & Appel Insurance.
Mark Gayer Vice President Personal Family Division
Mark Gayer serves as the Vice President Personal Family Division of Gregory & Appel Insurance.
Mary Schmid Vice President
Mary Schmid serves as the Vice President of Gregory & Appel Insurance.
Mike Salazar Vice President/Manager of Client Services
Mike Salazar serves as the Vice President/Manager of Client Services of Gregory & Appel Insurance.
How much do people at Gregory & Appel Insurance get paid? See the latest salaries by department and job title. The average estimated annual salary, including base and bonus, at Gregory & Appel Insurance is $89,260, or $42 per hour, while the estimated median salary is $209,375, or $100 per hour.
At Gregory & Appel Insurance, the highest paid job is a Recruiter at $177,286 annually and the lowest is a Receptionist at $41,706 annually. Average Gregory & Appel Insurance salaries by department include: Finance at $59,366, Marketing at $77,552, Admin at $43,946, and Business Development at $101,420. Half of Gregory & Appel Insurance salaries are above $209,375.
4 employees at Gregory & Appel Insurance rank their Compensation in the Bottom 15% of similar sized companies (based on 12 ratings) while 4 employees at Gregory & Appel Insurance rank their Perks And Benefits in the Bottom 25% of similar sized companies (based on 4 ratings).
Last updated months ago.
| Summary | Salary Range | Percentile |
|---|---|---|
1st Percentile $81k | $81k | 1st Percentile |
25th Percentile $152k | $152k | 25th Percentile |
50th Percentile $209k | $209k | 50th Percentile |
75th Percentile $233k | $233k | 75th Percentile |
100th Percentile $332k | $332k | 100th Percentile |
* Estimated salaries Estimated salaries are based on data provided anonymously by employees and/or estimated by other statistical methods.
The Diversity score provides insights into how diverse employees feel and rate their work experience at Gregory & Appel Insurance across various culture dimensions.
Gregory & Appel Insurance PTO policy is a critical component of the benefits package offered to employees.

No Recent Jobs found for Gregory & Appel Insurance on Comparably
Mark that you are interested and we will alert you when there are new positions available listed on Comparably

Candidates By Department
Engineering | 100% |
|---|
Candidates By Location
What is Gregory & Appel Insurance address?
Gregory & Appel Insurance location is at 1402 N Capitol Ave Ste 400
Who is the CEO of Gregory & Appel Insurance?
Gregory & Appel Insurance CEO is Dan Appel, their score by employees is 64
What is Gregory & Appel Insurance eNPS?
The eNPS for Gregory & Appel Insurance is -60
What is the salary for Marketing Operations in Gregory & Appel Insurance?
Marketing Operations average salary in the US is 81k
What are the salaries in the Operations in Gregory & Appel Insurance?
The average salaries for Operations in Gregory & Appel Insurance is 72k